Pizza restaurants

Peter's Pizza

4.1 173 reviews 11:00 AM - 11:30 PM 155 Columbus Dr, Carbonear, NL A1Y 1A6, Canada

Discover this place

Peter's Pizza, located at 155 Columbus Dr in Carbonear, NL, has undergone a remarkable transformation under new ownership. Customers are raving about the spotlessly clean environment and excellent service that now defines this beloved pizza restaurant. Jessica White highlighted significant improvements, stating that the food quality has drastically increased, shaking off its previous issues of inconsistency. With fresh, delicious pizzas taking the spotlight, it’s clear that the new management is dedicated to delivering a delightful dining experience.

Jerry echoes these sentiments, praising the quality of the pizza and the engaging staff, emphasizing that Peter’s Pizza is now a must-visit. The establishment offers a variety of menu options, including their famous garlic fingers, which Jason Billingham found irresistible when paired with donair sauce. Newcomers like Wigzz0316 enthusiastically endorse the crispy pizzas, solidifying Peter’s position as a top choice for pizza lovers in Newfi land.

Andrew Baker's rave review of the nachos adds another layer to the diverse offerings at Peter's Pizza. In summary, this restaurant has not only reclaimed its reputation but also elevated it, making it a must-try for anyone in Carbonear.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Counter service
Dessert

Amenities

Bar onsite
Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual

Crowd

College students
Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Peter's Pizza before visiting.

Reviews for Peter's Pizza

4.1

173 reviews

100%

40%

18%

21%

Review highlights

Based on 173 reviews

Peter's Pizza in Carbonear garners a generally positive reputation for its flavorful and fresh pizzas, with many customers praising the engaging and friendly staff. The establishment is noted for its cleanliness and an appealing menu that extends beyond pizza, including highly regarded nachos. Some reviews mention occasional inconsistencies in food preparation and wait times, though the staff's willingness to address issues is appreciated. Overall, the quality of the pizzas—crispy and well-seasoned—remains a strong draw, complemented by attentive service that enhances the dining experience. While a few operational hiccups have been noted, the brand maintains a solid local following due to its combination of food quality and customer care.

Jessica White

Jun 05, 2025

This location i have issues with. Windows wide open with no screens all summer, spiders dangling from the ceiling. Really quite the experience trying to play dodge the spider while waiting for supper. Food quality is inconsistant, meats on my pizza were raw after waiting well over an hour, they offered a replacement which took around 45 mins. The staff here are always super nice, but this location needs some serious renovations, inspections and new cleaning habits. UPDATE: Since the new owners took over there is such a drastic difference. Super clean, food is always great and the atmosphere is still awesome. I'd definitely recommend peters in carbonear to anyone now! Hats off to the new owners.

Jerry

May 21, 2025

New owner. Excellent pizza with excellent service. Spotlessly clean establishment and great menu. This is how you do Peter's Pizza. A on all aspects. Wonderfully engaging staff too. Do not pass this place. Eat here.

Wigzz0316

May 13, 2025

Very very good pizza. First time in today and I asked around about who has good pizza. I was told this is the spot and it sure was. Next time I'm up in Newfi land I'll know where to go for my pizza fix. Staff was great and pizza was fresh nice and crispy.

Jason Billingham

May 12, 2025

The pizza was great, but really saucy. The sauce wasn't overpowering, but we did take some off because it was bursting at the seams. The servers were really nice, but it took a bit longer than expected for them to take our order. Almost felt like we were forgotten about, but once our order was taken the food was out super fast. Now let's talk about the garlic fingers. Being from Ontario, garlic fingers aren't really a thing so I wanted to try them. Let me tell you that I could have eaten the whole pan by myself. I asked for donair sauce with it which just made it that much better. All in all a great experience and I'd recommend you give it a try if you're in Carbonear.

Andrew Baker

May 09, 2025

The absolute best nachos I’ve ever had!I’m seriously not kidding, I’ll be having them for sure the next time I order Peters!

David Bulbeck

Apr 17, 2025

Great food and decent prices. I look forward to having a chance to grab some more.

Seamus McDaid

Apr 16, 2025

Lovely place, very clean. Nice atmosphere and delicious pizza at an affordable price!

Amanda Hales

Mar 27, 2025

Great hidden gem. Off season, not much was open so tried this on a fluke. Very, very pleased! Great fast service for dine-in. The home made lasagna was amazing!